MIUI News Team

Rank: 6Rank: 6

Credits
23804
Device
Mi 6
Online time
372 Hours
Send PM

Mi VRRocket to FutureMIUI Lucky FridaySuper SaturdayMIUI Forum AppMIUI Happy MedalMi Bunny Game Master Discuss HereIndia Independence DayMIUI 8th AnniversaryScroll Of WisdomSurprise

[Reviews] Xiaomi Poco F1 vs OnePlus 6 vs Asus ZenFone 5Z: Which one is better ?

[ Promote]
5989 128 |
12:45, Aug-26-2018 | From PC
|
|
Go to reply no.
This post was edited by drlaxin at 22:58, Aug-27-2018

1.jpg

Hello MIUIers,

Xiaomi seems to have stirred the mid-range smartphone market segment by launching the Poco F1 smartphone. The brand has played on the same idea of delivering high-end specifications at an aggressive price tag, leaving its rivals like OnePlus 6 and Asus Zenfone 5Z behind. Here’s how the cheapest smartphone with the ‘most powerful’ mobile processor stands against its competitors:

2.jpg

Operating system: All run Android Oreo out of the box

Xiaomi Poco F1: MIUI for Poco based on Android 8.1 Oreo.
OnePlus 6: OxygenOS 5.1.9 based on Android 8.0 Oreo.
Asus ZenFone 5Z: ZenUI 5.0 based on Android 8.0 Oreo.

3.jpg

Processor: World’s ‘most powerful’ mobile processor powers all

Xiaomi Poco F1: Octa-core Qualcomm Snapdragon 845 processor.
OnePlus 6: Octa-core Qualcomm Snapdragon 845 processor.
Asus ZenFone 5Z: Octa-core Qualcomm Snapdragon 845 processor.


4.jpg

RAM: All come with 6GB and 8GB RAM options

Xiaomi Poco F1: 6GB RAM and 8GB RAM options.
OnePlus 6: 6GB RAM and 8GB RAM options.
Asus ZenFone 5Z: 6GB RAM and 8GB RAM options.


5.jpg

Storage: Same storage variants for all

Xiaomi Poco F1: 64GB, 128GB and 256GB storage options.
OnePlus 6: 64GB, 128GB and 256GB storage options.
Asus ZenFone 5Z: 64GB, 128GB and 256GB storage options.


6.jpg

Display: OnePlus 6 wins the race with AMOLED screen

Xiaomi Poco F1: 6.18-inch full HD+ (1080x2246 pixels) IPS LCD display with notch.
OnePlus 6: 6.2-inch full HD+ (1080x2246 pixels) Optic AMOLED display with notch.
Asus ZenFone 5Z: 6.2-inch full HD+ (1080x2246 pixels) Super IPS+ display with notch.


7.jpg

Front camera: Xiaomi Poco F1 stuffs-in more pixels

Xiaomi Poco F1: 20MP with f/2.0 aperture and AI mode recommendation.
OnePlus 6: 16MP with f/2.0 aperture with EIS.
Asus ZenFone 5Z: 8MP with f/2.0 aperture with EIS and 84-degree FoV.


8.jpg

Rear camera: OnePlus 6 gets the edge with f/1.7 aperture

Xiaomi Poco F1: 12MP with f/1.9 aperture + 5MP monochrome camera.
OnePlus 6: 16MP with f/1.7 aperture + 20MP camera with f/1.7 aperture.
Asus ZenFone 5Z: AI-powered 12MP with f/1.8 aperture + 8MP camera with 120-degree FoV.


9.jpg

Battery: Poco F1 leads with 4000mAh battery capacity

Xiaomi Poco F1: 4000mAh with Qualcomm Quick Charge 3.0 support.
OnePlus 6: 3300mAh with Dash Charging.
Asus ZenFone 5Z: 3300mAh with fast charging and AI-based management system.


10.jpg
  
Price: Xiaomi Poco F1 wins the price wars for all storage variants

Xiaomi Poco F1: 6GB RAM + 64GB (Rs 20,999, appx USD 300) , 6GB RAM + 128GB (Rs 23,999, Appx USD 343) and 8GB RAM + 256GB (Rs 28,999, Appx USD 415).

OnePlus 6: 6GB RAM+64GB (Rs 34,999, Appx USD 500), 8GB RAM+128GB (Rs 39,999, Appx USD 572) and 8GB RAM+256GB (Rs 43,999, Appx USD 630).

Asus ZenFone 5Z: 6GB RAM + 64GB (Rs 29,999, Appx USD 430), 6GB RAM + 128GB (Rs 32,999, Appx USD 472) and 8GB RAM + 256GB (Rs 36,999, Appx USD 530).



Source (for Comparison Criterias)


Verdict


In my opinion; Xiaomi Poco F1 is Clear Winner.


What do you think??
Which one is better ? Please Vote and Comment.

Related Threads:

Single-option Poll, 954 members voted
Your User group have no permission to vote
Favorite Share

Comment

nani67 poco f1 has a depth sensor not monochrome sensor  00:57, Oct-23-2018

Rated by 5 people   Experience Prestige Reason  

Dr.Arjun + 5 Awesome!
Biswajit@IND + 5 Poco f1
srvoleti + 1 Fantastic!
VikuBalupura + 10 + 5 Fantastic!
abhijitdevnath + 10 + 4 Fantastic!

Experience +31  Prestige +9  View Rating Log

Senior Member

Rank: 2

Credits
41
Device
0
Online time
2 Hours
Send PM
02:07, Aug-27-2018 | From APP
|
Technically none could compete with POCO F1 at that price...worth for money

Rated by 1 person   Experience Reason  

drlaxin + 5 Great!

Experience +5  View Rating Log

MIUI News Team

Rank: 6Rank: 6

Credits
23804
Device
Mi 6
Online time
372 Hours
Send PM

Mi VRRocket to FutureMIUI Lucky FridaySuper SaturdayMIUI Forum AppMIUI Happy MedalMi Bunny Game Master Discuss HereIndia Independence DayMIUI 8th AnniversaryScroll Of WisdomSurprise

 Author| 21:07, Aug-29-2018 | From PC
|
This post was edited by drlaxin at 23:27, Aug-29-2018

Dear,

Both the devices are Powered by Snapdragon 845 SOC and Same RAM Configuration (6GB and 8GB).

DlL8HyyUcAABU9B.jpg large.jpg
Screenshot_2018-08-29 POCO India ( IndiaPOCO) Twitter.png

Screenshot_2018-08-29 POCO India ( IndiaPOCO) Twitter(1).png

Poco F1 is equipped with Liquid Cool Technology which is not there in One Plus 6.

Liquid Cool Technology helps Poco F1 maintain sustained peak perfroamceand thus speed doesn't drop after continuous use.

Please revisit the launch event video (below) and watch it from 15:45 to 16:55 to understand this better.

DlL7V5jUUAAiUt2.jpg large.jpg

DlL7EsWUcAAL2jk.jpg large.jpg

DlL7dTOVAAEe8M-.jpg large.jpg

Another thing is App Startup and Latency comparison between both devices.  Please revisit the launch event video (below) and watch it from 53:40 to 58:10 to understand this yourself.


India Launch Event of Poco F1

Poco F1 is clear winner in terms of Speed.

Super moderator

Online

Rank: 8Rank: 8

Credits
161528
Device
Redmi Note 5/Pro
Online time
5119 Hours
Send PM

Mi  BunnyMi Water PurifierMi KeyMagic CubeYi Action CameraMijia Mi Bunny RobotMi Plastic In-ear PhonesMi HeadphonesNinebot MiniMi Bluetooth SpeakerMijia VR Play 2Mi VRMijia Electric ScooterXiaomi 6 LaunchMi MIXMi WiFiMi Notebook AirMijia Story TellerUnlock MedalMi HomeMi Band 2Mi TV 70Mi VR HeadsetMi BandMi Bluetooth Canon SpeakerMi Power StripMi Air PurifierMi Power Bank 10000MAH Mi Yi CameraMijia Smart ShoesMi Selfie StickMi BoxMi WiFi RouterMijia Walkie TalkieNinety Degree LuggageMi Kids WatchMi ScaleMi Power BankMi Bluetooth HeadsetMijia Qi CycleXiaomi 7th AnniversaryI Love MIUIFantastic!MIUI 2016MarshmallowMIUI 8Awesome!MIUI Devices ContestAnTuTuFlashholicMi TVMi 5 ProMi Pad 2 Win 10 EditionMi 5sRedmi Note 2Redmi Note 4Mi MIXMi 5Redmi 3Redmi Note 3Mi Note 2Mi 4cMi Pad 2Redmi Note4 Million Forum MembersRedmi 2Mi 4SXiaomi Mi 4Mi PadRedmi 1SMi NoteRedmi ProRedmi 3SMi 5s PlusMi Note ProMi Max 1500K Forum MembersMIUI 6th AnniversaryPokemon Master MedalMi Live MedalMIUI 50 Million UsersFan Of MIUI GreeceMIUI Weekly PollFan Of MIUI IndiaMIUI Fan From SingaporeI Love 20162100K Forum MembersMIUI Fan From IndonesiaMid-Autumn FestivalHappy DiwaliMerry ChristmasXiaomi 6th AnniversaryFan Of MIUI BangladeshThanksgiving DayDiwali 1 Million Forum App InstallsAtaturk Mourning1800K Forum MembersMIUI Marathon MedalMIUI Lucky Friday1700K Forum MembersMIUI 300 WeeksMIUI World TourFan Of MIUI SpainFan Of MIUI Poland1900K Forum MembersFan Of MIUI ItalyFan Of MIUI RussiaMIUI Forum AppHappy New YearFan Of MIUI FranceSuper Wednesday10 Million Forum Posts3 Million Forum MembersMIUI Philippines Fan MeetupWomen's Day MedalMIUI SXiaomi 5th AnniversaryCamera Filter Guru MedalMIUI Fan From NepalPuzzle MasterMIUI 9Super ThursdayMIUI Happy Medal300K Forum MembersRingolicious Medal3500K Forum Members100k Forum Members90000 Forum MembersSuper SundayMIUI Font LoverMIUI Fan From Philippines5 Million Forum App InstallsHappy Holi MedalSuper SaturdaySingapore Merlion MedalSurge S13 Million Forum App InstallsMIUI Fan from TurkeyMIUI Drawing TalentSuper Friday500K Forum MembersMIUI 100 Million UsersMIUI Monthly TalkMIUI 2017MIUI 20 Million UsersMIUI 7th Anniversary2 Million Forum MembersRooster Year of 2017MIUI PMIUI Fan from MalaysiaRocket to FutureHappy Valentine's DaySuper MondayMIUI Fan from IndiaSuper TuesdayMIUI 5th Anniversary1st AnniversaryI Love Mi BunnyGamer Mi BunnyMiPopSummer Mi BunnyAlpaca Mi Bunny MIUI ReviewMIUI News Team10 Million Forum MembersSurprise9 Million Forum MembersXiaomi 8th AnniversaryMIUI 10MIUI Halloween 201813 Million Forum MembersHeart to HeartSilver Super ModeratorDiscuss HereDual CameraMIUI 8th AnniversaryMIUI Weekly Devices Quiz8 Million Forum MembersQuick SurveyMIUI KingPioneer of MIUI English Forum Theme TalentMost Active MIUIerMIUI Android 4.4 KitKatMost Popular Forum UserRingtone Star Mi Story TellerUpdates LoverMIUI Ice Bucket ChallengeYouth PledgeMi Bunny Game Master India Independence DayMIUI G+ Follower2017 Annual AwardsStar Wars7 Million Forum MembersMIUI SuperstarMr. Dependable25 Million StrongRingtone ExpertMIUI Halloween 2017OTA FeedbackDie-hard MIUI FanScroll Of WisdomApp MasterHumor MasterMi TalentApp TalentDebate MasterInbox ZeroAndroid ElfMIUI FB FollowerMIUI Twitter FollowerForum Contest LoverMi Lover MedalAndroid GuruTechnology GuruMaster Of TechnologyStar Of TechnologyStar MIUI News Team MemberApp StarMi A1MIUI FollowerMIUI Medals CollectorApp TalentMIUI Expert

13:04, Aug-26-2018 | From PC
|
Definitely poco F1 is better

Rated by 1 person   Experience Reason  

drlaxin + 4 Thanks!

Experience +4  View Rating Log

Supreme Member

Rank: 7Rank: 7Rank: 7

Credits
26202
Device
Mi MIX
Online time
155 Hours
Send PM

Mijia Smart ShoesMi BandUnlock MedalMi  BunnyMi MIXMi TV 70Mi BoxMi T-ShirtMi Power BankMagic CubeMi Bluetooth HeadsetMi Notebook AirYi Action CameraMi HomeNinebot MiniNinety Degree LuggageMijia 360° Panoramic CameraMi Kids WatchMi WiFi RouterI Love MIUIFlashholicFantastic!MIUI Devices ContestAwesome!AnTuTuMi TVMi MIX2 Million Forum MembersMIUI SMIUI Marathon MedalMIUI Fan From PhilippinesSuper SundayMIUI Fan from Turkey5 Million Forum App InstallsMIUI Fan From IndonesiaHappy Singles' DayHappy Valentine's DayXiaomi 6th Anniversary1st Anniversary10 Million Forum PostsSuper MondayMIUI PWomen's Day MedalHappy New YearMIUI 50 Million UsersSuper SaturdayMid-Autumn FestivalRocket to FutureMIUI World TourMIUI 9MIUI Lucky FridayMIUI Weekly PollMerry ChristmasMIUI Happy MedalPuzzle MasterMIUI Forum AppFan Of MIUI IndiaMiPopGamer Mi BunnyAlpaca Mi Bunny Summer Mi Bunny25 Million StrongPioneer of MIUI English Forum MIUI KingMIUI 10MIUI Halloween 2018Humor MasterHeart to HeartPOCO F113 Million Forum MembersDiscuss HereScroll Of WisdomIndia Independence DayMIUI 8th AnniversaryMaster Of TechnologyDual CameraMi Drop10 Million Forum MembersQuick SurveyTheme TalentMi Lover MedalMIUI FollowerMr. DependableMIUI Quick DiscussionMIUI Halloween 2017Redmi Quiz MasterMIUI Twitter Follower2017 Annual AwardsStar Wars7 Million Forum MembersMIUI Medals CollectorDie-hard MIUI Fan6 Million Forum MembersAndroid ElfAndroid GuruStar Of TechnologyMIUI Weekly Devices QuizMIUI FB Follower5 Million Forum MembersDebate MasterSurpriseApp Star9 Million Forum MembersMIUI SuperstarMi Story TellerXiaomi 8th Anniversary8 Million Forum MembersForum Contest LoverBlack SharkOreoNougatOTA FeedbackMi Talent

13:16, Aug-26-2018 | From Mi MIX
|
Oneplus 6 because of its Amoled screen

Rated by 1 person   Experience Reason  

drlaxin + 2 Great!, I respect your opinion.

Experience +2  View Rating Log

Platinum Member

Rank: 4

Credits
3051
Device
Mi Max 128GB
Online time
10 Hours
Send PM

Mi MIXMi MIXRocket to FutureMIUI Marathon MedalI Love 2016MIUI Happy Medal10 Million Forum MembersMIUI 8th Anniversary13 Million Forum MembersMIUI Quick DiscussionAndroid GuruMi Lover MedalXiaomi 8th AnniversaryTechnology GuruMIUI King

14:08, Aug-26-2018 | From Mi Max 3
|
Poco phone for the win!

Rated by 1 person   Experience Reason  

drlaxin + 5 Thanks!

Experience +5  View Rating Log

Senior Member

Rank: 2

Credits
85
Device
0
Online time
0 Hours
Send PM

Rocket to FutureForum Contest Lover

16:10, Aug-26-2018 | From Redmi Note 4X
|
Price wise it would be Poco f1 other than that. There are features of the other phones greater than the poco

Rated by 1 person   Experience Reason  

drlaxin + 2 Thanks!

Experience +2  View Rating Log

Diamond Member

Rank: 5Rank: 5

Credits
882
Device
0
Online time
5 Hours
Send PM
21:35, Aug-26-2018 | From POCO F1
|
consider the price in India Poco F1 with 300$ is the best but in Europe the price of 5z and OP6 is around 550 650$ and when the retailer accidentally release the phone the lowest 6gb and 64 GB was aprox 575$ with a cutdown promo at 500$. tomorrow at Europe launch will se if that the price is what the retailer had given on 7 August

Rated by 1 person   Experience Reason  

drlaxin + 3 Thanks! Stay optimistic. So far this is

Experience +3  View Rating Log

MIUI News Team

Rank: 6Rank: 6

Credits
23804
Device
Mi 6
Online time
372 Hours
Send PM

Mi VRRocket to FutureMIUI Lucky FridaySuper SaturdayMIUI Forum AppMIUI Happy MedalMi Bunny Game Master Discuss HereIndia Independence DayMIUI 8th AnniversaryScroll Of WisdomSurprise

 Author| 21:47, Aug-26-2018 | From PC
|
hopa88 replied at 2018-8-26 21:35
consider the price in India Poco F1 with 300$ is the best but in Europe the price of 5z and OP6 is a ...

Many thanks for your time and feedback. Stay optimistic. you will not be disappointed with Global Launch / Pocophone launch. So far this is First and Only Smartphone with Flagship Snapdgragon845 and Available at Just USD 300. Find below reviews of Poco F1 by Top Tech websites or you can the thread http://en.miui.com/thread-3652540-1-1.html to know more.
Quick Review/ First Impression by Top Tech Websites

Xiaomi Poco F1 Review: The Budget Flagship has a New Benchmark
by TECHPP

POCO F1 review: Incredible performance at an unbeatable price
The POCO F1 is the most affordable Snapdragon 845 phone, and that isn't likely to change ever.

Xiaomi’s new Pocophone F1 undercuts rivals with a low price and high-end processor
by  The Verge

Xiaomi's Poco F1 phone threatens a price war
by BBC Tech Desk

Diamond Member

Rank: 5Rank: 5

Credits
882
Device
0
Online time
5 Hours
Send PM
01:37, Aug-27-2018 | From POCO F1
|
hopa88 replied at 2018-8-26 21:35
consider the price in India Poco F1 with 300$ is the best but in Europe the price of 5z and OP6 is a ...

i already have the phone and I paid 1999 RON that is 500$ :)I was the "lucky" guy that have the phone from 7 August :)

Diamond Member

Rank: 5Rank: 5

Credits
882
Device
0
Online time
5 Hours
Send PM
01:43, Aug-27-2018 | From POCO F1
|
hopa88 replied at 2018-8-26 21:35
consider the price in India Poco F1 with 300$ is the best but in Europe the price of 5z and OP6 is a ...

the bill :)
hEiSCGy_d.jpg


Super moderator

Happy To Help You

Rank: 8Rank: 8

Credits
159789
Device
Mi 6
Online time
2077 Hours
Send PM

Mi MIXMijia VR Play 2Mi VRXiaomi 6 LaunchMijia Electric ScooterNinebot MiniMi Bluetooth SpeakerMijia Walkie TalkieMijia Smart PTZ CameraMi  BunnyMijia Qi CycleMijia Story TellerMi Band 2Mi Plastic In-ear PhonesUnlock MedalMi HomeMijia Smart ShoesMi Power BankMi T-ShirtMi VR HeadsetMi WiFiMi Selfie StickMagic CubeMijia Mi Bunny RobotYi Action CameraMi Power Bank 10000MAH Mi ScaleMi HeadphonesMi BoxMi Kids WatchMi TV 70Mi Bluetooth HeadsetXiaomi 7th AnniversaryAwesome!MIUI 2016FlashholicAnTuTuMIUI 8I Love MIUIMIUI Devices ContestFantastic!Redmi Note 4Redmi 24 Million Forum MembersRedmi 3SRedmi Note 3Redmi 4/Prime/4AMi TVRedmi 4XMIUI World TourMIUI Fan From IndonesiaWomen's Day MedalSuper Thursday3 Million Forum Members10 Million Forum PostsHappy Singles' DaySuper WednesdayMIUI SHappy Holi MedalMid-Autumn FestivalSuper SaturdayMIUI Forum App5 Million Forum App InstallsMIUI Happy MedalFan Of MIUI RussiaPuzzle MasterSurge S1Super MondayRocket to FutureMIUI Weekly PollMIUI Fan from IndiaFan Of MIUI BangladeshRooster Year of 2017Happy Valentine's DayMIUI 20 Million UsersSuper SundayMIUI Lucky FridaySingapore Merlion MedalMerry Christmas3 Million Forum App InstallsMIUI 2017MIUI Fan from MalaysiaHappy New YearSuper TuesdaySuper FridayFan Of MIUI IndiaFan Of MIUI FranceMIUI Font LoverMIUI Philippines Fan MeetupMIUI 9100k Forum MembersXiaomi 5th AnniversaryAtaturk Mourning90000 Forum MembersMIUI 100 Million UsersMIUI PMIUI Fan From PhilippinesDiwali Happy DiwaliCamera Filter Guru MedalMIUI 5th AnniversaryMIUI 7th Anniversary1st AnniversaryFan Of MIUI Australia500K Forum Members3500K Forum MembersFan Of MIUI Ukraine300K Forum MembersRingolicious MedalFan Of MIUI PolandMIUI Fan From MyanmarMIUI 50 Million UsersMIUI Fan From NepalMiPopI Love Mi BunnyGamer Mi BunnyMIUI Device TeamMIUI ReviewGold Super ModeratorMi TalentOreoXiaomi 8th AnniversaryRingtone ExpertMIUI Weekly Devices QuizQuick SurveyMi Story TellerRedmi Note 5/ProIndonesia Independence DayStar Wars13 Million Forum MembersRedmi Quiz MasterPOCO F18 Million Forum MembersBlack SharkMIUI 10Heart to HeartRingtone Star Humor MasterMIUI Halloween 2018Silver Super ModeratorMIUI 8th Anniversary10 Million Forum MembersMr. DependableSurprise9 Million Forum Members7 Million Forum MembersNougatStar Of TechnologyApp StarMi Bunny Game Master Theme TalentMIUI Twitter FollowerMi Lover MedalMost Active MIUIerMIUI Expert25 Million Strong6 Million Forum MembersMIUI FollowerPioneer of MIUI English Forum MIUI Ice Bucket ChallengeMIUI Halloween 2017OTA FeedbackMost Popular Forum UserUpdates LoverMaster Of TechnologyMIUI KingMIUI Medals CollectorAndroid ElfAndroid GuruMIUI Quick DiscussionForum Contest LoverScroll Of WisdomMIUI Android 4.4 KitKatDebate MasterIndia Independence DayTechnology Guru2017 Annual AwardsMIUI SuperstarSuper ModeratorYouth PledgeDie-hard MIUI FanMi MIX 2MIUI G+ Follower

01:54, Aug-27-2018 | From PC
|
Why not POCO F1?

POCO F1 is better

Rated by 1 person   Experience Reason  

drlaxin + 5 Thanks!

Experience +5  View Rating Log

              Love Your Enemies as They Tell Your Faults

            Please use reply button to notify
                                

Credits Management

Quick Reply Top Return to the list